DjGubkafish's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Give it Pt. 2]

Sounds like jazz and dubstep to me . interesting combination

To be honest its hard to follow the melody because there is so many effects. Also some of the effects are too sudden and too noisy .

TheShowGuy responds:

too be honest there isnt alot of effects going on in the song its litterally just one snyth and piano

[Painless]

For someone who didn't make this song it may be difficult to catch the rhythm

Try to start with a single melody and work from it . There is virtually no progression,breakdown or ending . Just too much going on

Personally i find it easier if i make the entire song in a single VST and then you can add fancy effects

[Motions of Enigma]

Well i don't think you can call a 2 minute track a loop anymore ;) That is a looping song at that point

anyway

I like it . Although i think you should strive to make sound more consistent with volume and reasoning ( vibrant pads )

Some effects a bit painful for me . Just the vst choices could be a little batter

Banana responds:

Yeah I agree about the vst's. I'm currently in the process of finding better ones. Thanks for the feedback!

[Futurekeller]

the entire song doesn't really change aside from a few beats and snares.

That analog sound in the background . You can move it to lower register and switch it back and forth with the original every 20 seconds or so. That way you can have a bit more dynamic .

Even better just make a few analog melodies though .

jawalker213 responds:

Thanks for your feedback DjGubkafish! Glad to see there are strong opinions though I think the listeners have so far missed the point on this one

[Will of the Heart]

I heard this somewhere . Which part of this did you do because it sounds just like single midi

I won't actually rate because i am not sure . I mean i like it but is it really yours

MaSterAsSter responds:

Its from the anime series "bleach". Honestly, I just remade it by ear. Sort of a self challenge. I can say 100℅ that its not a midi though. :)

[GSI- Purgatory]

Its almost like you started uplifting-trance and went into dubstep .

I wish you would just brakedown trance part and make second part of the first melody .

1:14 That was just horrible to be honest . This is where trance melody brakedown needed to be .

[Roninarama]

as minimalist soundtrack for one of your games ots ok

I think this would be better if you could make it both melodic and minimalist .

Without the game its not something i would listen .

[Priapos]

Do you like old-school rpg games?

Melody is very pretty but drums kind of take away from the atmosphere a bit .

Chongo responds:

I actually never played that many old school RPG's. The only one really being Final Fantasy: Mystic Quest, but I've heard my music compared to it quite often, and considering the music heard in most of them, I take it as a compliment. As for the drums, I see where you're coming from and will consider that thought in the future

[Melancholy]

Vocals a bit pitchy . I can't blame a dude for wanting to sing though

So ill just vote on the quality of the music and 5 starts all the way

[Dream Wave]

This sounds way to similar to the original

If you want credit for remix you should at least change pace and change melody to a point where it sounds original .

There is like a thousand of remixes for this song and this one doesn't stand out to me .

kinggrinyov5 responds:

hmm strange, i decided to listen to the original before i uploaded this, and it sounded very different, would u be able to link me the one u heard. Thanks :P